Case Details
Share:

Case Snapshot
Case ID: 15353
Classification: Beating
Animal: dog (non pit-bull)
More cases in El Paso County, TX
More cases in TX
Abuse was retaliation against animal's bad behavior
Login to Watch this Case




Adopted dogs beaten, one dies
El Paso, TX (US)

Incident Date: Wednesday, Mar 18, 2009
County: El Paso

Disposition: Not Charged

Person of Interest: Frank Zimmerman

Case Updates: 2 update(s) available

Pet Guardian Angel staff members says a Fort Bliss soldier was arrested for killing one dog and hurting another after just adopting them from the facility two weeks before.

"It's hard to believe people can do that to an animal," said Sheila Smith, an administrative assistant at PGA.

Staff members at the nonprofit animal shelter couldn't believe what they heard when a Fort Bliss official arrived at the facility.

"That's very upsetting. We trust these people. We try to screen them as best we can to see if they can be responsible pet owners," said Smith.

Smith, who helps get animals at PGA adopted, said a young military couple adopted two dogs from PGA two weeks ago. Now, they hear the one named Tinkerbelle is dead. And a puppy named Wrigley has a broken leg and was returned to PGA. PGA staff said Wrigley was taken to Eastwood Animal Clinic for a broken leg at the expense of their organization.

The staff said the Fort Bliss soldier, Frank Zimmerman, beat the dogs.

KFOX spoke to the soldier's wife over the phone and she said Zimmerman didn't mean to hurt the animals. She said when the dogs weren't listening he would take his anger out on them. She said, "Frank beat Tinkerbelle with a leash and he stomped on her until she died."

"Not all military people are like that. Again, it's the way they're raised," said Smith, who was active military for years.

It is unclear what charges, if any, were brought against Zimmerman, but PGA staff says animal cruelty needs to be prosecuted better in El Paso.

"They need to be more strict. If someone is willing to harm an animal he's willing to kill a person. That's our concept," said Smith said.


Case Updates

A soldier accused of animal cruelty has been reduced in rank and faces separation from the Army amid news reports that he is suspected of killing his family's dog.

Spc. Franklyn Zimmerman, 22, of Fort Bliss, Texas, was reduced to E-1 and punished under Article 15 of the Uniformed Code of Military Justice, according to officials at Fort Bliss. The officials declined to provide any details but confirmed that Zimmerman was punished on an animal cruelty charge.

The officials declined to speak further because an Article 15 is nonjudicial punishment, and additional details of the case are protected by the Privacy Act.

Information released June 19 by Fort Bliss officials said Zimmerman is undergoing separation proceedings that "may result in a less than honorable discharge." The proceedings are expected to be completed by mid-July.

An Article 15 is less severe than a court-martial and is not a trial.

Local animal rights advocates and KFOX News, a television station in El Paso, Texas, have said Zimmerman is charged with animal cruelty for allegedly stomping on the neck of his dog, a golden retriever named Tinkerbelle, and killing her and breaking the hind leg of his other dog, Wrigley.

Zimmerman remains assigned to the barracks on post while he awaits his separation from the Army, a Fort Bliss spokesman said.

Zimmerman joined the Army in November 2005 as a multiple launch rocket system crew member, according to Army records. He re-enlisted in May 2007 and was going to reclass to military police.

The case against Zimmerman is the second animal abuse case this year involving allegations against a Fort Bliss soldier.

Sgt. Dwayne Sumter is accused of leaving his dog locked in a crate when he moved from Fort Bliss to his next assignment at Fort Hood, Texas, according to KFOX News. The dog chewed her way out of the crate but died without food or water, KFOX News reported.

Sumter, 29, was brought back from Iraq, where he was deployed with his new unit from Fort Hood.

The El Paso County district attorney is handling that case, the Fort Bliss spokesman said.

The case is still pending in local court. Sumter is charged with cruelty to nonlivestock animals, a misdemeanor.

Christina Koerber, a former resident of El Paso and animal rights advocate, brought together the U.S. Humane Society and the Fort Bliss Judge Advocate General to improve prosecution of alleged animal cruelty cases.

"Hopefully they'll work together to improve the system and implement change ... as well as prevent animal cruelty ... from happening again," she said. "Hopefully good's going to come of this."
Source: Army Times - July 5, 2009
Update posted on Jul 5, 2009 - 6:46PM 
Fort Bliss Spc. Zimmerman received an official reprimand and will be dismissed from the Army over animal cruelty charges.

KFOX reported that he is accused of stomping Tinkerbell, a golden retreiver, to death.

"She was standing so proudly in the picture that we have of her next to her family and what was going through her mind," said Evelyn Shannon, an animal advocate.

On Friday, Fort Bliss officials announced that Zimmerman will be reduced in rank and punished under what's called "Article 15" of the Uniform Code of Military Justice -- a nonjudicial procedure.

"It doesn't make a difference if you're a civilian or a soldier, this is uncalled for. It's unacceptable. And I don't like the fact that people say it was just a dog," said Donna Holmes, an animal advocate.

Zimmerman is currently undergoing separation proceedings, which may result in a less than honorable discharge.

But some animal advocates believe the Uniform Code of Military Justice failed. Rebecca Rojas with From the Heart Animal Rescue said she's disappointed with the outcome.

"There are members of the community that are rallying together to look at a situation, different situations to see if there's anything else that can be done," said Rojas.

Rojas said she hopes that community can learn from this case.

"It's a tragic, tragic situation, and we're hoping that the entire community can come together and make a difference for El Paso so that these situations can never happen again," said Rojas.
Source: KFOX - June 19, 2009
Update posted on Jun 20, 2009 - 11:09PM 

References

  • « TX State Animal Cruelty Map
    « More cases in El Paso County, TX

    Note: Classifications and other fields should not be used to determine what specific charges the suspect is facing or was convicted of - they are for research and statistical purposes only. The case report and subsequent updates outline the specific charges. Charges referenced in the original case report may be modified throughout the course of the investigation or trial, so case updates, when available, should always be considered the most accurate reflection of charges.

    For more information regarding classifications and usage of this database, please visit the database notes and disclaimer.



    Send this page to a friend
© Copyright 2001-2012 Pet-Abuse.Com. All rights reserved. Site Map ¤ Disclaimer ¤ Privacy Policy